When the Calendar Fights Back: Why Keeping a Schedule Is So Hard
We’ve all been there. You spend Sunday evening, coffee in hand, meticulously mapping out the week: the color-coded cleaning tasks, the perfect meal prep plan, the block of time carved out for a quiet prayer. You look at that schedule, and you feel powerful.
Then Monday morning hits.
The baby spits up on your ‘Tidy & Teach Tuesday’ laundry pile. School calls because someone forgot a necessary gym shoe. You realize you forgot to thaw the chicken. Suddenly, the perfect schedule isn’t a helpful map—it feels like a tyrannical ruler demanding obedience in a world built on chaos.
If you’re a mother, a creative, or just a human trying to live intentionally, you know the truth: Schedules are hard to keep. But it’s not always our fault.
The Three Reasons Our Schedules Fail
Our schedules often fail not because we’re lazy, but because we build them on shaky foundations.
1. The Myth of Perfect Control
When we build a schedule, we assume a level of control that simply doesn’t exist. As faith-filled individuals, we know that God ultimately holds the reins. Our schedules fail when they don’t allow for the unpredictable, the divine interruptions, or the reality of living with small, unpredictable humans. A good schedule is flexible; a bad schedule is brittle.
2. We Confuse Time Blocking with Life Stuffing
We try to cram too much in. We create 30-minute blocks for exercise, Bible study, and organizing the garage. While each task is good, the transition time—finding the gym clothes, settling the kids, finding the motivation—isn’t accounted for. We end up failing the schedule by 10 AM, and then we throw out the whole thing because we feel like we’re already behind.
3. It Doesn’t Reflect Our Reality (The North Dakota Factor)
You might live in Texas, North Dakota, or anywhere in between, but your physical reality matters. If you schedule an afternoon run at 4 PM in July in Texas, you’ll fail. If you schedule an hour of outdoor play in a North Dakota blizzard, you’ll fail. Our best-laid plans often ignore weather, geographical limitations, or even just the current energy levels of our family.
Shifting from “Schedule” to “Rhythm”
This is the mindset shift that changed everything for me. Instead of focusing on a rigid schedule (which is fixed and unforgiving), focus on establishing rhythms (which are fluid and natural).
- Schedule: “I must clean the bathrooms precisely at 10:00 AM every Monday.”
- Rhythm: “Monday is the day I focus on deep cleaning the main living areas and bathrooms, fitting it in between errands and lunch.”
A rhythm allows the purpose of the day to remain, even if the timing is shifted by an emergency phone call or a spontaneous dance party.
Three Ways to Build a Grace-Filled Rhythm
1. Identify Your Non-Negotiables
What truly must happen for your soul and your family to thrive? For me, it’s Mass on Sunday, 15 minutes of quiet time, and a tidy kitchen sink before bed. Anything else is secondary. If the non-negotiables get done, the day is a success, even if the rest of the schedule fell apart.
2. Schedule Space, Not Just Tasks
Build in “buffer zones” (15-30 minutes) between major activities. This is your time to transition, grab a drink, put away a few things, or answer a quick text. This buffer saves your entire schedule from collapsing when one task runs over.
3. Lead with Grace
When the schedule fails—and it will—don’t let the guilt win. View the disruption not as a failure, but as an opportunity for grace, flexibility, and sometimes, a little unexpected fun. Your family needs a present mother more than a perfectly executed routine.
The goal isn’t to be a scheduling robot. The goal is to use routine as a tool to support your intentional life, leaving plenty of room for God’s surprises.
What is the one part of your schedule that you are letting go of this week to find more peace?
suchismomlife.blog 